Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Immanuel Santosh's avatar

The XIRR-versus-corpus distinction is the most underrated part of this study. In retirement planning I keep seeing clients with a healthy 12-13% XIRR who are still years short of their target corpus, because the instalments they skipped were never made up.

The pattern is that the SIPs people skip are usually the ones during market falls, which are exactly the ones worth the most, and the "I'll catch up later" intention almost never converts into a lump sum.

The Multibagger Playbook's avatar

One thing on the market-fall test: the rule is anchored to the prior high, and the 2002 start sits right under the 2000 peak, so that investor sat out much of 2002 and 2003 by construction. How much of the roughly Rs 22 lakh gap comes from that opening stretch versus the post-2008 one? Rerunning from 2004 would show whether the result survives without the dot-com overhang.

Ready for more?